Substack vs Beehiiv vs Ghost in 2026: Which Newsletter Platform Is Best?
- Substack = best for beginners. Network effects (Recommendations), zero monthly cost, 10% revenue cut.
- Beehiiv = best at scale. Flat monthly fees ($0-$99/month), no revenue cut, better analytics, ad network.
- Ghost = best for full ownership. Self-hosted or hosted ($9-$199/month), no revenue cut, full customization.
Substack vs Beehiiv vs Ghost — Quick Comparison
| Feature | Substack | Beehiiv | Ghost |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cost (free tier) | $0 forever | $0 up to 2,500 subs | $9/mo (hosted) or self-host free |
| Revenue cut | 10% | 0% | 0% |
| Stripe fees | ~3% | ~3% | ~3% |
| Custom domain | $50/year | Free | Free |
| Network effects (Recommendations) | Strongest | Yes (Boosts) | None |
| Newsletter app | Yes | No (web only) | No |
| Notes / mini-feed | Yes (Substack Notes) | No | No |
| Analytics | Basic | Advanced | Advanced |
| Ad network | No | Yes (Beehiiv Ad Network) | No |
| Customization | Limited | Moderate | Unlimited (themes) |
| Membership tiers | Free / Paid / Founding | Unlimited tiers | Unlimited tiers |
| API | None | Limited | Full |
| Best for | Beginners | Growth-focused writers | Tech-savvy / agencies |
Substack — Pros and Cons
Pros
- Strong network effects — Substack Recommendations drive ~30% of new subs.
- $0 to start for free newsletters.
- Substack Notes for cross-promotion.
- Substack mobile app — readers love it.
- Easy to use for non-technical writers.
Cons
- 10% revenue cut — adds up at scale.
- Limited customization — hard to differentiate visually.
- Custom domain costs $50/year.
- No ad network for monetisation beyond paid subs.
- Limited analytics compared to competitors.
Beehiiv — Pros and Cons
Pros
- 0% revenue cut — keeps every dollar.
- Beehiiv Ad Network — earn from ads in your newsletter.
- Built-in referral program — incentivise sharing.
- Advanced analytics — segment subscribers.
- Boosts — pay other newsletters to promote you (and vice versa).
Cons
- Flat fees at scale ($49-$99/month for 5K-10K+ subs).
- No mobile app for readers.
- Smaller network than Substack.
- Newer platform — fewer integrations.
Ghost — Pros and Cons
Pros
- Full ownership — open-source, self-hostable.
- 0% revenue cut.
- Unlimited customization — themes, code injection, full HTML/CSS.
- Best-in-class SEO — Ghost is built for content sites.
- Full API — integrate with anything.
- Membership + content site all in one.
Cons
- Steeper learning curve — better for technical users.
- Self-hosting requires server expertise.
- No built-in network — you grow alone.
- Hosted plans more expensive ($9-$199/month).
- No mobile app.
Cost Comparison at 5,000 Paid Subscribers ($10/month each)
| Platform | Monthly revenue | Monthly fees | Net to creator |
|---|---|---|---|
| Substack | $50,000 | $5,000 (10%) + $1,500 (Stripe) | $43,500 |
| Beehiiv | $50,000 | $99 (Beehiiv Pro) + $1,500 (Stripe) | $48,401 |
| Ghost (hosted Pro) | $50,000 | $199 + $1,500 (Stripe) | $48,301 |
Annual savings of switching from Substack at this scale: ~$58,000/year. That's why most large Substacks consider migrating.
Which Platform Should You Choose?
| You are... | Best fit |
|---|---|
| Just starting out, <500 subs | Substack (free + network) |
| Hitting 1,000+ paid subs | Beehiiv (save the 10% cut) |
| Want full control + SEO website | Ghost |
| Tech-savvy and want self-host | Ghost (open-source) |
| Casual writer (no monetisation plan) | Substack (free) |
| Already have an audience | Beehiiv or Ghost (skip Substack network) |
| Building a media business | Ghost |
Migration: Substack → Beehiiv or Ghost
Both Beehiiv and Ghost have Substack import tools:
- Export your Substack subscriber list (free, instant via Settings).
- Import to new platform (Beehiiv: Settings → Import; Ghost: Settings → Members → Import).
- Re-set up your About, branding, payment processor.
- Optionally: keep Substack alive as archive while migrating.
Most writers experience ~5-10% subscriber loss during migration (re-confirm emails, etc.) — accept it as cost of switching.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Substack better than Beehiiv?
For starting out, yes (free + network effects). At scale, no — Beehiiv saves you the 10% revenue cut.
Can I move my Substack to Beehiiv?
Yes. Export your subscribers from Substack (Settings → Import/export), then import via Beehiiv's Substack-specific import tool.
Does Ghost cost more than Substack?
Ghost has flat monthly costs ($9-$199), but no revenue cut. At 1K+ paid subs at $10/month, Ghost saves you money vs Substack's 10% cut.
What's the cheapest newsletter platform?
If self-hosted Ghost: ~$5/month (server costs). Hosted: Beehiiv free tier (up to 2,500 subs) or Substack (free with 10% cut).
Which platform has the best analytics?
Beehiiv and Ghost both offer advanced analytics (segments, attribution, A/B tests). Substack's analytics are basic.
Key Takeaways
- Substack = free + best for beginners (network effects).
- Beehiiv = no revenue cut + ad network (best at scale).
- Ghost = full ownership + best SEO (best for tech-savvy).
- At 1K+ paid subs, switching from Substack saves $5K-$50K/year.
- Migration tools are mature — switching is easy.
One bio link works on every platform
Whether you're on Substack, Beehiiv, or Ghost — drive subscribers from social media via a single UniLink URL. Free with click analytics.
Create Your Free Link-in-Bio Page
Join thousands of creators using UniLink. 40+ blocks, analytics, e-commerce, and AI tools — all free.
Get Started Free